Thoughts from the criminology team

Home » Posts tagged 'health'

Tag Archives: health

Here we go again… medical misogyny continues

Rant time!

Back in August, I received a letter and text from the NHS telling me the time had come for my cervical screening- joy of joy! Women between the ages of 25- 64 years are invited for their cervical screening every 5 years. For many women, the process is simple, the procedure (if you can call it that, it’s a swab for those who aren’t aware) is also simple. But for some, the experience can be daunting, and painful. The letter tells you to book on ASAP, the text provides a link, and reminds you of the importance of attending your screening. Hesitate I do not – I book on!

The first available appointment is the end of October (2 months away!). Not ideal: in August, as many staff and students will be aware, our timetables haven’t settled and are subject to changes. Trying to select a day I don’t think I’ll have classes is basically guess work at this stage. Guess I do, and guess accurately I’ve managed. Well done me! The letter contains information on why the screening is done, what is looked for and to request a female nurse if preferred…. Erm yes! There is also information about brining/requesting a chaperone if required – good to see. But I cannot find any information about what happens if women are on their periods or pregnant. Must not matter (spoiler alert: I’m wrong. It matters!).

Rock up to my appointment (2 months down the line), currently on day 2 of my period. Bleeding heavy, managing horrific cramps, light-headedness whilst having had minimal sleep (standard day 2 joys for me). I walk rather than drive to the appointment (safety first). When I am eventually called into the room, it’s confirmed I am there for a cervical screening, but I interrupt to inform them I have a tampon in and assume I need to take this out before the swab is taken. Oh no! I cannot have the cervical screening today as they cannot take it when people are bleeding (something to do with if a positive or abnormal result they cannot differentiate between the cells). I am told I should have cancelled and re-arranged. I should not have booked the appointment for when I was on my period and that I need to book an appointment for when I am not bleeding. I should have known.

Well… why should I have known? I had looked on the links sent with the link to book the appointment and I couldn’t find anything about bleeding. I was asked why I had not ‘simply asked AI’ if I was unsure. Great. Dr’s surgeries suggesting I use AI to ask medical questions… that doesn’t feel appropriate. I figure I don’t have time to list off all the issues I have with AI, and I’m not sure the nurse would care. I also have this pesky issue of a chronic illness which means my periods resemble Niagara Falls, cramps often leave me immobile and they are irregular (which basically means they show up whenever they feel like it and last from anywhere between 3-8 days): fun for me! So how can I ensure I book a time I’m not bleeding? I track my periods so I have general idea when I should roughly start bleeding- but I’m often early or late, rarely am I on time. And if there isn’t an appointment available then, what do I do?

I leave the appointment having re-arranged for a few weeks later when I should be blood free (fingers crossed). But I feel angry, deflated, exhausted and emotional. I have just had to defend why I didn’t know, why I wouldn’t use AI and how I am supposed to book appointments on a system which is based on the assumption that women have regular periods. Oh how little still appears to be known about women’s bodies. Or is this it is known and it is deliberately ignored? Either way, I’ll add it to my tally of b*****it medical experiences where my body is the issue, rather than the system and assumptions made which leave women on the fringes of proper medical care.

I have since done some deeper digging: the NHS web page does have information about bleeding and pregnancy: https://www.nhs.uk/tests-and-treatments/cervical-screening/how-to-book/

So not knowing is on me- although why this wasn’t included in the link sent from the Drs when booking I don’t know. Also, as a 25 year old new to the joys of a smear test, why would you be thinking about this? I overthink and was basically panicking about remembering to take the tampon out if required (forgetting you have a tampon in has quite serious consequences- and is something I frequently struggle with due to the sheer number I go through). Feels like pretty essential information. Also, appointments months away, on the assumption that women track or are regular with their bleeding is such a ridiculous approach. I mean, there is a significant possibility myself (and others) will be in a consistent cycle (unlike their periods) of booking and then re-arranging appointments until finally their menstrual cycles align with the NHS calendar… and by then months or years could have passed with the possibility of dire consequences. So…guess it’s just a regular day at the office then for women and healthcare…

Will Keir Starmer’s plans to abolish NHS England, help to save the NHS?

In a land-mark event, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer has unveiled plans to abolish NHS England, to bring the NHS back into government control. Starmer justifies much of this change with streamlining operations and enhancing efficiency within the NHS, that in recent years has faced a backlash following long queues and an over-stretched staff pool. Moreover, this is part of Starmer’s plan to limit the power of control from bureaucratic systems.

NHS England was established in 2013 and has taken control and responsibility of the NHS’s daily operational priorities. Primarily, NHS England is invested in allocating regional funds to local health care systems and ensuring the smooth delivery of health care across the NHS. However, concerns, particularly in Parliament have been raised in relation to the merging of NHS England and the Department’s of Health and Social care that is alleged by critics to have brought inefficient services and an increase of administrative costs.

Considering this background, the plans to abolish NHS England, for Starmer come under two core priorities. The first is enhancing democratic accountability. This is to ensure that the expenditures of the NHS are contained within government control, thus it is alleged that this will improve efficiency and suitable allocation of spending. The second is to reduce the number of redundancies. This is backed by the idea that by streamlining essential services will allow for more money to be allocated to fund new Doctors and Nurses, who of course work on the front line.

This plan by Starmer has been met with mixed reviews. As some may say that it is necessary to bring the NHS under government control, to eliminate the risks of inefficient services. However, some may also question if taking the NHS under government control may necessarily result in stability and harmony. What must remain true to the core of this change is the high-quality delivery of health care to patients of the NHS. The answer to the effectiveness of this policy will ostensibly be made visible in due course. As readers in criminology, this policy change should be of interest to all of us… This policy will shape much of our public access to healthcare, thus contributing to ideas on health inequalities. From a social harm perspective, this policy is of interest, as we witness how modes of power and control play a huge role in instrumentally shaping people’s lives.

I am interested to hear any views on this proposal- feel free to email me and we can discuss more!

Let’s talk about sex!  

Very few topics receive attention as much as sex.  A very primal human behaviour that gets people talking.  In Criminology any discussion on sex contains those elements that make it less than appealing, abuse, exploitation and violation.  Our focus on the criminal dimensions of sexual behaviour can disfigure the way we talk about it and misrepresent the joys of sex.  It can be argued however that outlining the negatives gives way to a positive outlook to sex in a similar way to health professional’s focus on avoiding sexually transmitted diseases, leading to a healthy sexual life. 

Sex is about affirming social relations, as part of our own intimacy.  There is a variety on sex from feelings, practices and expressions that is as wide as humanity itself.  It is a language we talk that needs no translation.  This is why that abusive behaviours are regarded such a violation of the person.  Rape, legally, is as serious as murder.  The person victimised is losing something so intimate that it may never be recovered; one of the many reasons why people who suffered abuse are called survivors. 

Our perspectives on sex changes and our society tried to accommodate them.  Some years ago, Holland decided to include some scenes on “public liberal expressions on sexuality” as part of their material for their immigration test.  This is a marked difference from the UK who decriminalised homosexuality but only behind closed doors.

Criminologically speaking there are certain elements that safeguard sexual behaviours.  Age, relation, location and consent.  The age of consent is recognising the minimum age any person can be legally responsible to engage in sexual relations.  Under that age and it is statutory rape.  Any relationship between close relatives in the UK can lead to imprisonment.  Any sexual acts in public are regarded illegal, including sex in public toilets (cottaging) so sex remains behind closed doors.  The final point is the most controversial; consent is paramount to any sexual relations.  The important thing in sex is that we choose to engage with others or not.

Part of the criminological process is to ascertain how we understand consent and disseminate it to others.  Academically there are several issues to consider and to investigate.  This is one of criminology’s strengths to tap into the sociological and philosophical discourses offering some practical perspectives.  In recent years the discussion about sex on campus for example has been one that raised awareness on consent.  In criminology we discuss it in ways to amplify the importance of consent in sex and in relationships in general. 

For a long time now, we have talked about safe spaces as a mechanism of allowing people to talk without judgement.  We focus on educational practices that are focused on inclusion and empathy and disseminate work that challenges established notions that mythologise sexual relations and minimise the importance of consent. 

Let’s explore some of the key points we disseminate. Sex is an individual right for all regardless of origin or identity, which makes it also a universal right.  Law safeguards sexual relations, but the lack of reporting of sexual violence, the low conviction rate of those processed cases and the volume of unknowns underscore that we cannot resolve sexual violence legally.  We cannot police sexual relations when our community does not prioritise the importance of safeguarding human rights.  What we can do instead is to change that social discourse on sex.  In one of my previous posts, I underscored the irony of proliferating legal interventions, whilst culturally we seem happy to receive expressions on misogyny, abuse and exploitation as legitimate expressions on sexuality.  Policing sexual behaviours for example comes with a long history of retaining the straight man’s privilege of pleasure over all others.  A privilege long retained unchallenged making the work of current and future criminologists even more pressing! At the end of this month, it is International Day of Consent in November 30, so from today until the end of the month, ask yourself what you have done to change the established narrative to make your own space more inclusive.